Skip to main content

Book Review: The Tribute by Dash Benhur

‘The Tribute’ is a short story widely popular in the Indian schools. Ironically, the author of this great story is anonymous.

The relevance of this story never chugs out of time; it is a fit story for all times, as it shuttles between the strong themes, like redemption and sacrifice. Babuli, the protagonist of the story, often remembers his schooldays and the contribution of his elder brother in shaping his life. Subsequently, he is settled in a city and living a happy married life.

However, a sense of contrition never leaves him because he has not written a letter to his mother and the elder brother, who live in the village, for almost two years. He is settled in a city, have a job and a wife, i.e. life. Probably, for this reason, he feels not so much concerned about his family that lives in the village in not so good status.

One day, he receives a letter from his elder brother. The letter is about the partition of the ancestral land, home, and everything that was heaped by their parents in their lifetime.

By all calculations, Babuli's share stands up to twenty thousand rupees. It is a hefty amount for his wife, who keeps pestering him for an active participation in the ancestral property. She also suggests that from that money they will be able to buy a scooter, washing machine, jewelry and other things. She is full of materialism, as she says, “What is the use of village land for us? On the other hand, Babuli begins resenting his ungratefulness towards his family. He has a hunch that he has forgotten the people who had helped him to shape his future.

The interesting point of conflict is that the wife of Babuli is not concerned about Babuli and his family. She just wants her share to enjoy life. The morality of a woman can decline for the sake of hedonistic gains is something evident in the Indian societies. But Babuli is hesitant to take up a stance against her materialistic aspirations.

After the death of his father, it was his elder brother who got in the fatherly role to support his education and there was one event of financial stress where he mortgaged his favourite watch to arrange the fees for Babuli.

While going to his village on a bus, he is lost in the reminiscences of his childhood days, and his mind and heart are flooded with the memories of old days when he was a school-going kid.

He remembers how his brother would carry his bag when he returns from the school, carry him on his shoulders while crossing the fields, and one night when Babuli was shivering under a thin blanket the elder brother had put his blanket over him and left for the field early in the morning.

It is the middle brother of the family who wants the partition on the behest of his wife. He is ready to buy Babuli's share for the sum of twenty thousand rupees. When Babuli reaches the village, he finds an unusual silence gnawing the ambiance of the house; the elder brother and mother are extremely silent.

Babuli is shying away to meet gaze with any of them. He is shamefaced for his actions - that he remained aloof to them for long after getting a job and everything. He did not even bother to attend their problems nor helped them monetarily. In all senses, it is becoming clear that Babuli is a selfish man.

Babuli remained silent throughout the division, and the next day before leaving for the city he hands over a letter to the wife of his elder brother. In the letter, he expresses his wish that he doesn't want any share of the property. He dedicates his entire share to his elder brother as a tribute to love and sacrifice he made shaping his life.


  1. Author's name is Dash Benhur (Jitendra Narayan Dash) and he is not anonymous. Irony is that its me who is commenting as anonymous for the fact which says that author is anonymous!


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Book Review: The Blue Umbrella by Ruskin Bond

Binya is a poor little girl living with her mother and an elder brother, Bijju, in a very small hilly village of Garhwal. One day while herding her two cows back home, she stumbles upon some city people enjoying the picnic in the valley. She is enthralled to see them rich and well-groomed. She craves to be one like them and among many other things of their, a blue frilly umbrella catches her attention. She begins craving for it. On the other hand, the city people get attracted by her innocent beauty and the pendant in her neck. The pendant consists of leopard’s claw – which is considered a mascot widely in the hills. Binya trades her pendant off with the blue umbrella.

The blueumbrella is so much beautiful that soon it becomes a topic of conversation for villagers and children adore her umbrella so much that every time they feel like to touch or hold it. Binya is on seventh heaven and rarely closes it because she believes it looks charming when it is opened.
Ram Bharosa runs a small …

Book Review: The Lost Child by Mulk Raj Anand

The Lost Child is a riveting short story by Mulk Raj Anand. A little boy and his parents are on their way to a village fair on account of a spring fair. The alley leading to the fair is alive with a vivid combination of colours and people.

The boy is happy and chirpy and walking between the big limbs of his father, between the long strides. As he can see there are toys in the shops lined along the way. He is captivated by the colourful toys of different sizes and shapes but in his observation he lags behind. So he runs ahead to be with his parents. When he expresses the desire to own one of the toys hanging from the shops, a cold stare from his father breaks his heart.
Suddenly, to break his attention from the lingering toys, his mother tenderly shifts his attention to the swaying muster field, which seems to be full of golden ripples – moving to and fro. The boy enters the field and begins chasing butterflies, black bees and dragon flies. But soon he is called back.
Once they appr…

Book Review: Sparrows by K. A. Abbas – A Story about Hidden Kindness

K. A. Abbas was a master at writing short stories, presumably influenced by O. Henry. His work presents a different picture of India and is mainly based on humanity. He was the contemporary writer of that colonial India when the cinema used to run in black and white. Reading K.A. Abbas means exploring the old culture of India.
‘Sparrows’ is a brilliant short story. Once, the story ‘Sparrows’ was conscripted in the world’s best stories along with ‘The Lost Child’, written by Mulk Raj Anand.
A bit about Sparrows
Rahim Khan, the protagonist, is a stolid figure, almost devoid of emotions. He lives alone and the whole village is fearful of him because he brutally beats children and men on slightest pretexts. With time, he has grown so obtrusive and rough that streaks of humanity have left him. Why is he like that?
During the magnificence of his youth there was no one who could compete with him in the wrestling and other sports. It's his deepest desire to join Circus folk. In addition …