Skip to main content

Book Review: Sons and Lovers by D.H. Lawrence

Gertrude Coppard hails from a better off family. An evening when Christmas dance event has been going on she chances upon a handsome, but unsophisticated, young man. He is Walter Morel – an insignificant coal miner. They fall in love at first sight; rather it is an infatuation which is sweeping their hearts. Despite huge social differences, the couple marries.


They have four children, out of which three are sons. Walter Morel proves to be a failed husband, he often spends his time at the pub after working hours and the family suffers in poverty. Household agitation and tension begin gnawing the well being ambience of the house. The couple often quarrels on slightest pretexts, and the drunkard Morel feels no shame in thrashing her to vent his pent-up frustration of being socially failed.

To escape his rage, she turns her attention to children. She is overly focused on William, the eldest one. He is successful at his work so he moves to London to raise his standard of life. One day he returns home with his girlfriend, Lilly. Gertrude disapproves her by labelling her shallow and self-centered. William plunges into tension and soon as a result dies of fever in London.  

Gertrude finds herself unable to come out of the shock until she realizes that her second son Paul is on the brink of death due to pneumonia. She nurses him and they both develop a deep bond of love and comfort for each other. Next, Paul meets Miriam, a poor girl from a farm who attends the same church as Paul.

Their acquaintanceship stretches over four years. They are in love. However, Paul discovers that his mother dislikes Miriam for more than one reason. She isn’t as beautiful and capable as Gertrude, and she isn’t rich. Above all excuses Gertrude longs to see her son successful and rich rather than haggling with poor souls like Miriam. Due to his mother’s reactions toward Miriam, Paul begins to leave her. Miriam is somewhat spiritually elevated figure – lacking punch of sexual appeal frustrates Paul. Thus to get him that, she introduces Clara Dawes to him on her farm. Infatuation bonds them. Paul and Clara seem to be good match and hold a healthy intimacy. Gertrude has vapid feelings for Clara but still she doesn’t approve her for a marriage match. On the other hand, Clara refuses to divorce her husband Baxter, whom Paul loathes.   

Paul gets entwined among the female forces and gradually he realizes that his closeness and inspiration drawn off his mother is debilitating him in creating relationships with other women in his life. He fails with all and when his mother dies of cancer he finds himself in a void of emptiness.

Sons and Lovers by D. H. Lawrence is a lovely novel that seeks to explore the forces existing in relationships. Paul, one of the main characters, feels the heat of this force and in the end when his mother passes away he feels empty from within.

He was so much attached to his mother that he was blinded to find other women worth of anything. In a sense Paul’s mother was suffering from streaks of solipsism – and her quest to find things perfect in other women causes Paul a great discomfort.

However the way Lawrence presented his characters and their circumstances in which they undergo change is praiseworthy.     

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Sparrows by K. A. Abbas – A Story about Hidden Kindness

K. A. Abbas was a master at writing short stories, presumably influenced by O. Henry. His work presents a different picture of India and is mainly based on humanity. He was the contemporary writer of that colonial India when the cinema used to run in black and white. Reading K.A. Abbas means exploring the old culture of India.
‘Sparrows’ is a brilliant short story. Once, the story ‘Sparrows’ was conscripted in the world’s best stories along with ‘The Lost Child’, written by Mulk Raj Anand.
A bit about Sparrows
Rahim Khan, the protagonist, is a stolid figure, almost devoid of emotions. He lives alone and the whole village is fearful of him because he brutally beats children and men on slightest pretexts. With time, he has grown so obtrusive and rough that streaks of humanity have left him. Why is he like that?
During the magnificence of his youth there was no one who could compete with him in the wrestling and other sports. It's his deepest desire to join Circus folk. In addition …

Book Review: Godan by Munshi Premchand

Like many other poor peasants Hori too wants to own a cow in a hope to elevate his puny social status to some height of self-importance. Much opposite to his circumstances, he purchases a cow on debt of 80 rupees. However things spiral out of his control when he tries to cheat his younger brother, Heera, by 10 rupees. This haggle causes a huge fight between Dhaniya (Hori’s wife) and Heera’s wife; and then next Heera poisons the cow and escapes away to avoid being caught by the Police.

To settle down the cow’s death matter, Hori takes some loan from a moneylender and bribes the police. On the other hand, Gobar (Hori’s son) has an affair with a widow Jhunia. When Jhunia is pregnant with his child, Gobar runs away to the city to escape the wrath of the villagers. But then Jhunia is taken into care by Hori and his family. Because of Jhunia’s issue, the village Panchayat orders Hori to pay a penalty amount in lieu of his son’s deeds. Thus, Hori again takes the loan from moneylenders.
As t…

Book Review: Untouchable by Mulk Raj Anand

The novel – Untouchable needs no introduction for an Indian reader because its background is well known to him.The very title is a telltale.
Humanism, which is the key concept of his novels like Untouchable and Coolie, reveals man’s essential dignity and nobility. According to this approach to man – man is the creative source of infinite possibilities. Mr. Anand is a humanist who reveals the essential dignity of the underdogs of Indian society. Anand in all his novels emphasizes the fact that nobility and dignity are not the monopoly of the rich. The poor have their greatness, honour as well as the richness. This humanism is the central theme of his novels. His humanism justifies that man is man, be he a sweeper, a prince or a coolie.
The novel Untouchable has the confrontation between tradition and modernity. Anand realized that much in the Indian tradition was obsolete and meaningless. Tradition might have its utility when it began as a new practice. But in course of time, it lost…